Job gains signal US doing better than GDP shows |
Home > Career Advice > Market Watch > Job gains signal US doing better than GDP shows

Job gains signal US doing better than GDP shows

Published on Sunday, 28 Jul 2013
In a sign of US economic recovery, companies such as General Electric plan to keep investing and hiring. (REUTERS)
Trucks are parked near new homes rented by oil workers in Williston, North Dakota – reflecting the buoyancy of the US national economy. (AFP)

WASHINGTON: Judging by the figures for growth, the US economy is in the doldrums. Labour-market data tell a more positive story.

Payrolls climbed by 202,000 a month on average from January through June, up from 180,000 in the second half of 2012, according to the Labor Department. Such gains are typically linked with gross domestic product (GDP) growing close to 3 per cent, about double what government data may show this week, according to economists at UniCredit Group and Deutsche Bank Securities.

“The employment numbers are closer to the true picture,” said Harm Bandholz, chief US economist at UniCredit in New York and the top payroll forecaster in the past two years, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. “I’m confident GDP growth will pick up in the second half and even more in 2014.”


The weight of the evidence also tips the balance towards a more favourable outcome as federal tax receipts rise at the fastest pace in six years, measures of consumer confidence reach the highest levels since at least 2008, and sales of autos and homes and housing rebound. That helps explain why companies from General Electric to construction materials supplier Texas Industries plan to keep investing and hiring.

After adjusting for the increase in rates that took effect this year, employee income-tax withholdings were up about 6 per cent in June compared with a year earlier, the best showing for that month since 2007, according to calculations based on Treasury data by Joseph LaVorgna, the New York-based chief US economist at Deutsche Bank. More receipts point to gains in employment, rising wages or a combination of both.


“Tax receipts are confirming the improvement in the labour market, but GDP seems to be overstating the weakness in output,” said LaVorgna.

GDP in the first half of the year gives the impression of a “lousy” economy, while it’s actually been “decent”, he said. It “reinforces the view that the second half will be better,” he adds.

Growth in the first half of 2013 was restrained by the effect of federal government cutbacks and increase in taxes which is likely to wane. Slower inventory building and a wider trade deficit also curbed the expansion last quarter, when GDP rose at a 1 per cent annualised rate, according to the median forecast in a Bloomberg survey ahead of Commerce Department data due on July 31. The economy grew at a 1.8 per cent pace in the first quarter.


GDP is the sum of all goods and services produced as tracked by consumer spending, government outlays and business investment on such things as plants, equipment and inventories. It also includes the value of exports minus imports.

Expanding job openings, home prices that are growing at the fastest pace since before the recession and record-high equity values are helping shore up household confidence.

The Bloomberg Consumer Comfort Index climbed last week to match the highest level since January 2008 as Americans grew more upbeat about the economy. A similar measure from Thomson Reuters/University of Michigan issued on July 27 reached a six-year high for July.

More confident consumers are spending on big-ticket items. Cars and light trucks sold in June at the strongest pace since November 2007, according to Ward’s Automotive Group. Ford Motor on July 23 said it will hire 3,000 salaried employees this year, 800 more than originally planned.


The housing rebound is another sign of an improving economic outlook. Texas Industries, a supplier of construction materials, finished commissioning a 1.4 million-ton cement facility and acquired 42 ready-mix plant sites in the quarter to May 31 to capitalise on growth in the east Texas market. The Dallas-based company is accelerating work on an old kiln to bring back production capacity by early 2014.

United Rentals said it purchased more equipment and hired 93 sales people towards its goal of adding 120 to 150, and expects a “robust back half of the year.” The Connecticut-based building-equipment rental company’s recent surveys show key clients remain bullish and a record-low number of customers expect a decline in business conditions.

“We’re exactly where we want to be in the recovery, with higher rates, volume, and utilisation on our larger fleet,” said Michael Kneeland, United Rentals’ chief executive officer. “It tells us that the market activity is picking up.”


The disconnect between hiring and growth may begin to narrow when, along with second-quarter growth figures, the Commerce Department this week issues GDP revisions, said Neil Dutta, head of US economics at Renaissance Macro Research in New York.

The government annually updates the growth data by incorporating more complete information that is only available with a lag. This year will be a more comprehensive overhaul, something that is done about every five years, and will include changes in the way GDP is calculated, which could potentially affect the figures back to 1929.

GDP “looks increasingly like the outlier” relative to other data such as corporate profits, said Dutta. “Overwhelmingly, the signals are that the economy is not only doing OK, but doing better than a lot of people think.”

A stronger economy would make Federal Reserve projections easier to achieve this year and next, said Dutta. In June, Fed officials forecast the US will grow 2.3 per cent to 2.6 per cent this year and 3 per cent to 3.5 per cent in 2014.


Gains in income and profits are another sign that growth is probably stronger than currently thought, according to Joseph Carson, director of global economic research at AllianceBernstein in New York.

Fed research has shown that gross domestic income (GDI), or the money earned by the people, businesses and government agencies whose purchases go into calculating growth, is a better gauge of the economy. After multiple revisions over time, the growth estimates tend to align more closely with the income figures, rather than the other way around, according to a 2010 paper by Fed economist Jeremy Nalewaik.

GDP has increased at a 3.4 per cent annualised rate since the third quarter of 2012 before adjusting for inflation, while GDI grew at a 4.9 per cent pace, Carson said. He projects the economy’s growth rate will be revised up for the past few years when the update is released on July 31.


While the lingering effects of the worst recession in the post-World War II era – including diminished productivity following the plunge in business investment – have contributed to slower growth, “it’s certainly credible that the GDP number has been undercounted,” said James O’Sullivan, chief US economist at High Frequency Economics in Valhalla, New York.

“The employment data are strong enough already to be consistent with at least a 3 per cent pace of GDP growth,” he said.

Companies such as Connecticut-based General Electric are gearing up to meet demand. GE is investing in the aviation and oil and gas divisions, opening factories and making purchases, including Lufkin Industries, to boost manufacturing and service operations.

“Orders in the US were the strongest we’ve seen in some time,” and backlogs grew, chief executive Jeffrey Immelt said on GE’s earnings teleconference on July 19. “You’re going to get some gathering momentum I think in the second half of the year.”


Become our fans